How some friendships last — and others don’t

How Some Friendships Last — and Others Don’t: The Secret Science of Lasting Bonds
Article by - Arya Bandyopadhyay

Why Friendships Matter More Than You Think

Friendships are more than just fun hangouts and shared memories. They’re essential to our well-being. Did you know that having strong friendships can boost your immune system, lower stress, and even extend your lifespan by up to 22% (Holt-Lunstad et al., 2010)? While some friendships last for decades, others seem to fade away for reasons we can’t quite explain. So, why do some friendships thrive while others fall apart? The answer lies in the fascinating world of neuroscience, psychology, and biology. Let’s break down the science behind lasting friendships and uncover why some bonds endure.

A moment of connection: friends enjoying time together, demonstrating the power of shared experiences in strengthening bonds. Photo by Felix Rostig on Unsplash

Step 1: The Magic of First Connection

The beginning of any great friendship has its roots in simple yet powerful factors:

Proximity & Repetition: You’re more likely to form lasting friendships with people you encounter frequently. This phenomenon, called propinquity theory (Festinger), shows that being around someone often sparks familiarity and, eventually, affection.
The Similarity Effect: We’re drawn to people who share our beliefs, interests, and values. When we connect on a deeper level, our brain releases feel-good chemicals, reinforcing the bond.
Brain Chemistry at Play: When you meet someone and click, your brain releases oxytocin — the “trust hormone.” This boosts feelings of comfort and connection (Kosfeld et al., 2005).

How Men and Women Connect:

Men often bond through shared activities like playing sports, working on a project, or enjoying a hobby together.
Women tend to form deeper connections through emotional sharing, mutual support, and offering a listening ear (Rose, 1985).

Recommended Reading: Friendfluence by Carlin Flora, The Psychology of Friendship by Mahzad Hojjat & Anne Moyer

Step 2: Building Trust — The Friendship Formula

Trust is the foundation of any lasting relationship. Here’s how it’s built:

Give and Take: Friendships thrive when both people contribute. This balance triggers dopamine, the “feel-good” neurotransmitter, reinforcing loyalty.
Neural Synchrony: When close friends chat, their brainwaves actually sync up. This synchronization strengthens their connection and makes conversations smoother (Dikker et al., 2021).
Attachment Styles Matter: According to Bowlby’s attachment theory, people with secure attachment styles tend to have healthier, more stable friendships.

A Gendered Perspective:

Female friendships can sometimes feel like a lot of emotional labor. They require frequent check-ins and reassurance.
Male friendships, while often more low-maintenance, can struggle if emotional support is lacking (Benenson, 2014).

Building memories around the campfire: friends coming together to create lasting bonds through shared experiences and meaningful moments. Photo by Kimson Doan on Unsplash

Recommended Reading: Attached by Amir Levine & Rachel Heller, Vital Friends by Tom Rath

Step 3: Vulnerability: The Secret to Deepening Friendships

The key to moving from casual acquaintances to lifelong friends? Vulnerability.

Opening Up: Friendships become stronger when we share personal stories, fears, and dreams. Being vulnerable with a friend creates emotional intimacy (Aron et al., 1997).
Facing Stress Together: When friends go through challenging times together, it strengthens their emotional bond. This is because stress activates the brain’s emotional and memory centers, making the friendship more memorable.
Sharing New Experiences: Doing new things together releases dopamine, helping create lasting memories and deepening the bond.

How Men and Women Bond:

Men often deepen their friendships by doing activities together, like playing sports or working on a project.
Women often bond by sharing personal stories, offering advice, and providing emotional support.

Recommended Reading: Big Friendship by Aminatou Sow & Ann Friedman, The Friendship Formula by Caroline Millington

Step 4: Navigating Conflict and Distance — What Makes Friendships Resilient?

Embracing the beauty of nature and friendship: a serene moment capturing the joy of being present with those who matter most. Photo by Antonino Visalli on Unsplash

Every friendship faces bumps in the road. But what makes some friendships stronger after conflict?

Forgiveness: Empathy helps repair relationships. When we forgive, it activates the prefrontal cortex, which helps us let go of anger and heal the relationship (DeWall et al., 2011).
Adaptability: Life changes — new jobs, marriages, kids, or moves — can test friendships. But those that adapt to life’s transitions are the ones that last.
Effort Balance: A friendship thrives when both people invest in it. If one person is doing all the work, the friendship may start to feel one-sided and fade away.

The Gender Angle:

Women’s friendships are often rich in emotional depth but may be more vulnerable to breakdowns after betrayal.
Men’s friendships tend to dissolve more quietly, often due to neglect rather than direct conflict.

Recommended Reading: The Social Brain by Robin Dunbar, Friendship: Development, Ecology, and Evolution of a Relationship by Daniel J. Hruschka

Step 5: Keeping the Friendship Alive — The Invisible Work

Friendships require effort, even when they’re going well. Here’s how to keep them strong:

Stay in Touch: Even a quick message can activate your brain’s reward system and keep the friendship alive.
Create Shared Rituals: Inside jokes, weekend hangouts, or annual trips act as anchors that keep the bond steady.
Cognitive Availability: Simply thinking about your friend or reminiscing about shared experiences can strengthen the bond.

Gender Dynamics:

Female friendships often require consistent emotional investment and care.
Male friendships, on the other hand, can survive on shared activities, even without frequent check-ins.

Recommended Reading: Social by Matthew D. Lieberman

Why Friendships Fail — and What the Science Says About It

Sometimes, despite our best efforts, friendships fall apart. Here’s why:

Effort Imbalance: When one person puts in more effort than the other, the friendship becomes lopsided, causing emotional exhaustion and withdrawal.
Life Disruptions: Major changes — like moving, getting a new job, or entering a new relationship — can disrupt friendship dynamics.
Trust Violations: Betrayal triggers pain in the brain, often causing irreparable harm to the relationship.
Attachment Style Differences: Conflicting attachment styles (e.g., anxious vs. avoidant) can create instability and tension in friendships.

Gender Notes:

Female friendships are more likely to break down after trust is violated.
Male friendships often fade gradually due to neglect, rather than through a confrontation.

Recommended Reading: Friendship: Development, Ecology, and Evolution of a Relationship by Daniel J. Hruschka

Navigating Vulnerable Friendships — When Romantic Feelings Emerge

It’s common for feelings to get complicated when one friend starts to develop romantic feelings. Here’s how to handle it:

Crushes and Emotional Blur: When one friend develops romantic feelings, it can create tension. Dopamine — the reward hormone — is released, and it might feel like the friendship is shifting.
Communication Is Key: To prevent misunderstandings, talk openly about the feelings you’re experiencing (Baumeister & Leary, 1995).
Set Boundaries: If both parties want to preserve the friendship, it’s essential to set clear boundaries to maintain trust and emotional safety.
Dual-Process Strategy: Focus on friendship-affirming activities to keep the bond strong, while being mindful of behaviors that might escalate romantic tension.

The Gender Perspective:

Men may struggle with romantic feelings due to evolutionary drives.
Women may feel emotionally conflicted when deep friendship overlaps with attraction.

With open communication, these friendships can not only survive but grow stronger in mutual respect.

Recommended Reading: Can Men and Women Be Friends? by Deborah L. Tannen, The Science of Relationships by Gary W. Lewandowski Jr.

Positive Takeaway: Friendships Are More Than Just Socializing — They’re Biological Necessities

Having strong, supportive friendships:

Boosts your physical health and immunity
Lowers stress and protects against anxiety and depression
Extends your life by up to 22%

Friendships are not a luxury — they’re a biological imperative.

Conclusion: Friendships Are Dynamic Systems

Think of your friendships like a living, breathing system. They need regular care, emotional balance, and the flexibility to grow.

By understanding the science behind friendships and the nuances of gender dynamics, you can cultivate lasting, meaningful bonds that not only survive but truly thrive.

Actionable Steps to Strengthen Your Friendships

Reach Out — Send a message or make a call today.
Plan an Activity — Do something fun together.
Express Gratitude — Let your friend know they matter.
Practice Forgiveness — Let go of old grudges.
Stay Vulnerable — Share openly and listen actively.
Invest Time — Make time for each other regularly.
Embrace Change — Be flexible as life changes.
Create Traditions — Build lasting rituals that strengthen your bond.
Resolve Conflicts Early — Tackle tension before it grows.
Stay Loyal — Speak kindly of your friends, even when they’re not around.
Handle Romantic Tension with Care — Communicate clearly and set boundaries.
Check in Emotionally — Take time to gauge how your friend is feeling.
Avoid Scorekeeping — Focus on generosity, not keeping score.
Support Each Other’s Growth — Encourage your friends to reach their personal goals.

Growth — Encourage your friends to reach their personal goals.

Friendships are an art, and with care, they can flourish and deepen over time.

Celebrating friendship and freedom: a joyful moment of togetherness, showing how shared joy strengthens the bonds that last. Photo by Simon Maage on Unsplash

Search This Blog

Fresh Science Trends